For a million years I was a staunch Blackberry supporter. At the time,
Research In Motion’s Blackberry was the clear leader in the wireless handheld market. Other companies tried to introduce products to compete with the “berry”, but none could even come close to the ease of use and elegance of the RIM device. That is, until
Apple moved into town.
When the iPhone first came out I was not interested in the least. My Blackberry served me very well, and since I wasn’t a Mac person, I figured I wouldn’t be interested. But with all the hype (there’s an app for that!) and cool things I was hearing about the iPhone, I figured it was time to check it out. Also, the company that I worked for at the time had some clients with iPhones and it was very hard to support their needs when none of us knew how they worked. I bought my iPhone in May 2009 and never looked back. My only regret was that I loved the physical keyboard on the Blackberry and the touch keyboard of the iPhone took some getting used to. Other than that, the iPhone was the clear winner.
During my time with the iPhone (I purchased an iPhone 3G with AT&T service – the 3GS and version 4 were not available at that time) I was amazed at the functionality of the device. Things like stock prices and the weather were only a touch away. It easily integrated with my Gmail account, and, sadly for me, with my work accounts too. The little handheld did it all. I was in love. However; our love affair wasn’t all roses and candy. My device had a nasty habit of not working in 3G mode. After many frustrated calls to AT&T customer service, I discovered (on my own) that the handheld would only function with the 3G service turned off. This meant that any over-the-air tasks were painfully slow. I watched as Steven blissfully downloaded apps at blazing speeds on his 3GS, while I waited and waited for the cute picture of a puppy to load on my phone. I spoke with several people who echoed my sentiment. Supposedly these issues were fixed in later versions of the devices, but being locked into a two year contract was keeping me right where I was, with no hope of a new phone in sight for many months.
I really have to give Apple credit for the thoughtfulness of the iPhone OS. It is super-easy to use and virtually impossible to break. Installing apps is a snap, and removing them is even easier. This is a phone that most anyone can use. I especially like that text message notifications are right there waiting for you when you fire up the screen, and communicating via email or text is incredibly easy. While AT&T’s voice and data service isn’t the best, for the most part, this phone hasn’t let me down.
Enter the Android
In September 2008,
Google launched the
Android operating system. Using a free licensing model, the Android phones quickly became available from a number of mobile phone devices. It is estimated that the Android OS is being delivered to 300,000 handsets daily. That’s a huge number. With all the hype of the Android, I figured it was time to check it out.
The Metro PCS Dilemma
I am currently paying AT&T $95 every month for my iPhone. That just seems ridiculous to me. My AT&T contract doesn’t end until May 2011, so if I want to cancel I will need to pay an Early Termination Fee. AT&T structures the fee (for contracts started prior to a certain date in 2010) at $175, less $5 for every month of used service. In my case, that would be a $75 penalty for early cancellation. Next comes the question of service. Who should I go with? We bought a phone and plan for my niece from
Straight Talk, who is tethered to the Verizon network. Her service is $50 a month, and includes unlimited voice, text, and web service. She is happy with the service. I looked at their phones and wasn’t happy with the selection. The only potential iPhone replacement was priced at almost $300. That wasn’t in my budget for this experiment. Next, I checked out Metro PCS. I am not a fan of Sprint service, but Metro PCS has a flat $50 monthly plan with no contract for their service. And they had an Android that thought was OK on sale for $100. That’s where the honeymoon ended. When I walked into one of the Metro PCS stores I was amazed at the number of people waiting in line. There had to be 50 people queued up for help. I walked right back out the door. The next store I went to was out of the phone I wanted (and pretty much every phone model). Disappointed, I decided to try one more store near my house. They had the phones, but were holding them for people on a waiting list. The lady at the store was very nice and sold one of them to me since many people hadn’t been coming in to claim their phones. After paying $150 ($100 for the phone and $50 for the first month of service), I walked out of the store with my new phone. As an interesting side note: The number that they have me must have been from a drug dealer, because this phone was ringing off the hook from the second I turned it on. At all hours of the day and night people were calling this phone. The calls seemed to have died down now, but it was an aggravating first day with multiple calls from people I didn’t know.
The Android – first few days
The first thing that delighted me about the Android was the lack of security code to unlock the device. With the iPhone you can use a four digit code to unlock the phone. It’s easy and works well, but the Android has a clever pattern-matching system that seems much more secure. I’m not terribly worried about someone hacking into my phone, but I thought the pattern-matching was quite elegant. Also, there is a very cool voice search feature where you simply speak your search query into the phone and a browser opens up to Google with the search results. This may be available as an iPhone app, I don’t know, but I was impressed with the feature being available right out of the box.
I am going to stay away from model-specific functionality of the phone that I purchased, as it isn’t relevant here, but I will say that the phone I purchased has five buttons on the device, as compared to the single button on the iPhone. Advantage: iPhone in this case.
The OS comes pre-loaded with all the usual apps: mail, calendar, web browser, etc. Being a Google product, Gmail and Google Talk are prominently displayed on the desktop. Missing my stock and weather apps, I hopped over to the Android Market to download them. They were easy to find and the download process was simple. The only caveat was that unlike the iPhone, I had to initialize the application once it was downloaded. Not a huge deal, but I kept searching for my apps after download, only to discover that there was an additional step to load them.
There are tons of apps for the Android, something I was wondering about. There is an app for anything available for the iPhone and I wondered if the same is true for the Android. So far there hasn’t been an app that I have not been able to find. I will say that if you are an iPhone user, you might find navigating around the Android a bit of a chore. Some things like wallpaper location and sending a picture run differently than they do on the iPhone, but, all in all, it is a solid operating system and I am going to trudge on using it. Metro PCS, on the other hand, might not be the service for me. We shall see.